Fall Installation Event: $3,000 OFF any complete metal roof replacement

Book by October 31 to lock in this season's pricing

Claim My Savings
Metal Roofs Direct
Iowa Homeowner's Guide

Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles

Two ways to roof the same house — one bought once, the other bought again and again. Here's how they really compare when Iowa hail, wind and freeze-thaw winters are what your roof has to survive.

  • ✓ Free in-home estimate
  • ✓ 50-year transferable workmanship warranty against covered roof leaks
  • ✓ Flexible financing available
Get My Free Quote
Stone-coated metal shingle roof on an Iowa home

Decide With Facts

Hail

Iowa sits in one of the country's most active hail corridors. Asphalt shingles lose protective granules with every significant hailstorm, and bruised shingles are a common storm claim. Steel panels resist impact, and severe weather can cause cosmetic changes without necessarily affecting roof performance.

Wind

Straight-line winds and derechos peel lifted shingle tabs off in strips. Our snap-seam panels engage concealed clips along their edges with no exposed fasteners, and stone-coated steel panels are secured in overlapping courses — there are no loose tabs to catch and tear away.

Longevity

Iowa's freeze-thaw cycles, summer heat and hail gradually wear an asphalt roof down until it needs replacing again. A properly installed metal roof is commonly the last roof a home needs — many homeowners replace their asphalt roof more than once before a metal roof is replaced.

Side by Side

The honest comparison, line by line — including where asphalt genuinely wins.

What MattersAsphalt ShinglesMetal (Our Systems)
Storm responseGranules wash away with each hail event; lifted tabs tear off in high windSteel sheds hail and resists uplift; severe weather may cause cosmetic changes without affecting performance
Fasteners & seamsThousands of nails through individual shinglesSnap-seam locks panels over hidden clips; stone-coated steel fastens in overlapping courses
Replacements over timeUsually replaced more than once over the life of a metal roofCommonly the last roof the home needs
WarrantyManufacturer coverage that typically diminishes with the shingle's age50-year transferable workmanship warranty against covered roof leaks, plus manufacturer coverage on both of our systems
Upfront costLower initial price, paid again at each replacementHigher initial price, spread across decades instead of repeating
LookThe familiar standard, with color fading and granule loss over timeStone-coated profiles that read like premium shake, or crisp snap-seam standing-seam lines

Coverage is subject to the written warranty’s terms, conditions, exclusions, registration and eligibility requirements. Manufacturer warranties are issued by the manufacturer. Normal weathering and cosmetic changes from environmental exposure may not affect roof performance and may not be covered. The signed warranty documents control.

The Iowa Factor

An Asphalt Roof Is a Subscription. Metal Is a Purchase.

Every asphalt roof eventually bills you again — for the tear-off, the haul-away and the new shingles, often in the middle of the storm season when crews are booked out. A metal roof ends that cycle: it's engineered in 26-gauge steel to be the roof your house keeps, through the hail, the derecho winds and decades of Iowa winters.

Pick This If You Want the Shingle Look

Stone-coated steel gives you the depth of premium shake and dimensional shingle profiles — with a 50-year limited manufacturer warranty against covered product defects and steel underneath instead of asphalt.

Explore Stone-Coated Metal

Pick This If You Want Clean Lines

Snap-seam is 26-gauge textured steel with concealed fasteners and a standing-seam look — sourced directly from the manufacturer to help keep costs down, with a 40-year limited manufacturer paint-finish warranty.

Explore Snap-Seam Metal

Common Questions

Is a metal roof worth it compared to asphalt shingles in Iowa?

For many Iowa homeowners, yes — because the deciding factor isn't the sticker price, it's the storm cycle. Hail and high wind can shorten an asphalt roof's life or end it in a single afternoon, and the roof is replaced again and paid for again. A metal roof is designed to ride out that same weather for decades, so the cost is spread across far more years. Your exact numbers depend on your roof's size, pitch and details — request a free quote to see what the comparison looks like for your home.

How does a metal roof handle Iowa hail?

Steel is far tougher than the mineral surface of an asphalt shingle. Hail that bruises or granule-strips a shingle roof generally leaves metal panels looking the way they started. Severe storms can still cause cosmetic changes to metal — a dent or a surface mark — without necessarily affecting the roof's performance. If a hailstorm ever damages your asphalt roof, that's a replacement cycle; on a metal roof, it's usually not.

What about wind and storms?

Asphalt shingles are individual pieces with an adhesive seal and nail heads that can be lifted by sustained wind, and once a tab peels, water gets in fast. Our systems are built differently: snap-seam panels engage concealed clips along their edges with no exposed fasteners, and stone-coated steel panels overlap and interlock so there are no loose tabs to catch the wind.

How much longer does a metal roof last?

Long enough that many homeowners replace their asphalt roof more than once before a metal roof would ever need replacing. Freeze-thaw cycles, summer heat and repeated hail gradually wear asphalt down; steel is not consumed the same way. Both of our systems also carry a 50-year transferable workmanship warranty against covered roof leaks.

If metal lasts longer, why do people still choose asphalt?

Usually for the lower upfront price, or because they're planning to move soon. But an asphalt replacement you pay for twice can cost more over the years than a metal roof paid for once, and a metal roof is something a future buyer sees as a feature. There's no single right answer — that's why the estimate is free and comes with no obligation.

Will a metal roof look out of place on my home?

No. Our stone-coated steel comes in profiles like Cottage HD and Pinecrest Shake that read like premium dimensional shingles and cedar shake from the street. If you prefer clean architectural lines instead, the snap-seam system delivers a standing-seam look. Both are available in a range of colors.

Do you install in my city?

We install across Iowa, including Des Moines, West Des Moines, Waukee, Clive, Urbandale and surrounding communities. See the full list of service areas, or request a quote and we'll confirm your address.

Ready for a Roof Built to Last?

Get My Free Quote